Judge refuses to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit

A proposed class action alleging that Micron, Samsung and SK hynix coordinated supply cuts will move forward, though the court has made no finding on the merits.

ComputingPublished
What happened
Judge Noël Wise denied a motion by Micron, Samsung and SK hynix to dismiss a proposed class action accusing them of DRAM collusion.
What’s new
The judge rejected the companies' argument that the suit merely repeats a 2018 antitrust case, finding the plaintiffs had shown new evidence.
Why it matters
Memory prices have risen by up to 500% in a year, and the case now moves toward arguments over whether that stemmed from coordination.

Judge Noël Wise has turned down a request by Micron, Samsung and SK hynix to throw out a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing the three memory makers of colluding to limit DRAM supply, Tom's Hardware reported on 15 November.

The companies had argued that the case was a rerun of an antitrust suit brought against the industry in 2018. According to Tom's Hardware, the judge rejected that argument because the plaintiffs had pointed to new evidence suggesting collusion. The manufacturers said they track each other closely because competition is tight. Judge Wise wrote that the conduct alleged was instead "more akin to hawks flying in formation".

The plaintiffs, 17 individuals and small businesses, allege four parallel moves that restricted supply and contributed to a shortage in which prices climbed by as much as 500% in one year. These include production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, a subsequent shift toward HBM, announcements within three months of each other that DDR4 production would wind down, and a failure to add capacity despite high prices. They also cite strict customer vetting, refusals to sign long-term contracts, Micron's closure of its Crucial consumer brand, and the companies' involvement in past price-fixing cases.

The chipmakers counter that these were independent business decisions in a concentrated market where all three face the same pressures. The ruling only means the claims are plausible enough to proceed; it is not a judgment. The companies have until 7 December to respond to the complaint, and a case management conference is set for January 2027.