San Diego ends its Flock camera and smart streetlight program
The city council rejected both Flock's licence plate reader software and Ubicquia's smart streetlights, three years after city leaders pushed the program through over privacy objections.
- What happened
- San Diego's city council voted to drop Flock's AI licence plate reader cameras along with the Ubicquia smart streetlights that worked alongside them.
- What’s new
- The vote reverses the city's 2023 approval, which the mayor and other municipal leaders had urged at the time.
- Why it matters
- This is the second time in under a decade that San Diego has adopted smart streetlights and then abandoned them.
San Diego's city council has voted to end the city's use of Flock cameras, Ars Technica reports. The rejection also covers the smart streetlights from Ubicquia that ran alongside Flock's AI-driven automatic licence plate reader (ALPR) software.
Police representatives defended the program at the council meeting on 16 November. According to Ars Technica, they said vehicle theft has fallen 20 percent since 2023 and that the Flock cameras led to the recovery of 689 stolen vehicles.
The decision reverses the city's position from three years earlier, when the mayor and other city leaders urged the council to approve the program. Ubicquia had acquired a smart city platform and, in partnership with Flock and with police support, proposed an installation of 500 cameras. The system was installed in 2023. At that time, the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Board asked the council to reject the plan.
This is San Diego's second attempt at smart streetlights. The city previously bought thousands of streetlight systems from another vendor, GE Current, and a previous mayoral administration shut them down in 2020.
Pegah Parsi, a member of the Privacy Advisory Board, wrote on LinkedIn that she now feels vindicated, and she urged other cities to heed the expert boards they set up. Brian Hofer, executive director of the Oakland-based advocacy group Secure Justice, told Ars in an email that his group has documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended. Hofer said the cancellations span cities of all sizes in both red and blue states.