Satya Nadella warns much critical infrastructure is unpatchable

Microsoft's CEO said internet-connected firmware in chillers, HVAC and transport systems cannot be fixed. He also warned that AI-era pressure to patch instantly will create instability.

SecurityPublished
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella smiling.
Image: Brian Smale and Microsoft / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped · Source · Licence
What happened
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella spoke at The New York Times' DealBook Summit on 18 November about vulnerable infrastructure and AI-aided cyberattacks.
What’s new
Nadella said a lot of internet-connected infrastructure firmware cannot be patched. He also said patches now have to reach production immediately because flaws are exploited in the wild.
Why it matters
The head of a major software vendor is saying that faster patching driven by AI threats carries its own operational risks.

Microsoft chief executive Satya Nadella used an appearance at The New York Times' DealBook Summit on 18 November to warn that much of America's infrastructure runs on software that cannot be fixed, TechCrunch reports. "There is a lot of stuff in our critical infrastructure that's unpatchable," Nadella said.

Nadella pointed to firmware in chillers, which are cooling equipment common in data centres, and in HVAC systems, noting that these devices are connected to the internet. He said he had also heard about transportation systems whose exposed firmware cannot be patched.

According to Nadella, the response will require modernising those systems. It will also mean assessing the threat and how well organisations can detect and defend against attacks in real time.

Nadella also argued that AI is cutting both ways for software security. He said there is now a very powerful tool for finding vulnerabilities, while AI has also made sophisticated attacks easier to carry out. In the past, he said, companies had more time to test and roll out fixes. Now a patch must move straight from release into production because the flaw is already being exploited, and he warned that this will create instability.

The remarks followed a run of large-scale outages, including one affecting Microsoft Outlook. TechCrunch notes that some people have speculated these outages were cyberattacks, which officials have denied. Nadella attributed the Outlook disruption to a dormant bug that combined with other conditions. He said Microsoft had issued an incident response and would apply the lessons to both its architecture and its operations.