Study finds school phone bans modestly improve learning

Researchers from Harvard and Dartmouth say in-school phone bans equal one to two extra school weeks, and now want Meta's teen restrictions to test out-of-school use.

GadgetsPublished
What happened
A Harvard, Dartmouth and NWEA study of 3.3 million US students found in-school cellphone bans produced modest learning gains.
What’s new
The study used student-level data rather than school averages, and its lead researcher proposes using Meta's settlement restrictions to study after-school phone use.
Why it matters
According to the researchers, bans are a cheap way to recover roughly half of US learning loss seen since 2013, though the remaining loss is unexplained.

Banning cellphones in US schools has an effect equivalent to adding one to two weeks to the school year, according to a study by researchers at Harvard University and Dartmouth College working with assessment group NWEA, The Verge reports. The researchers say that is about half of the learning loss US students experienced between 2013 and the covid-19 pandemic.

The team analysed test data from 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools, with and without bans, from the 2021–22 to 2025–26 school years. Unlike an earlier nationwide US study based on school-level averages, this one used individual student data, which the researchers say let them control for more factors. They found similar gains across age groups and little difference by achievement level.

The researchers also argue bans are cost-effective: lockable pouches for a class of 17 would cost an estimated $425 per teacher, against $2,080 to pay an average teacher for an extra week.

Tom Kane, faculty director of Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, told The Verge that phone use outside school may explain much of the remaining loss. He wants to test that using restrictions on under-18 users that Meta agreed to in a $17.1 billion settlement with nearly every US state, many of which are expected to take effect within months.

The Verge notes two obstacles: there is no easy way to tell whether teens actually use Meta's apps less or simply move to other apps, and researchers would need to link the restrictions to school results. Kane says platforms could help by sharing de-identified, aggregated data grouped by school.