Supreme Court keeps block on DEI research grant cancellations

The Supreme Court declined to intervene, so lower-court rulings stand that treated the government's cancellation of individual DEI-related research grants as likely viewpoint discrimination.

FrontierPublished
The Supreme Court of the United States . Washington, D.C.
Image: Photo by Mr. Kjetil Ree . / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0, cropped · Source · Licence
What happened
The Supreme Court left in place a preliminary injunction that restores research grants the government had cancelled over DEI.
What’s new
The justices did not intervene, so the appeals ruling finding likely First Amendment viewpoint discrimination still stands.
Why it matters
Ars Technica says other courts may read the decision as a sign that the government's anti-DEI efforts rest on shaky legal ground.

The US Supreme Court has kept in place an injunction against the government's cancellation of research grants linked to diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), Ars Technica reported on 16 November.

The researchers whose grants were terminated argued that the cancellations amounted to viewpoint discrimination in violation of the First Amendment. A District Court agreed with them. It issued a preliminary injunction that would restore their grants, and a Court of Appeals panel upheld that ruling.

The appeals panel drew a distinction between two kinds of action. It said the government may scrap entire grant programs it no longer considers appropriate. Terminating particular grants because it disagrees with them, however, is an attempt at "suppression of dangerous ideas," the panel said. To support this, the panel relied on Supreme Court precedent on religious viewpoint discrimination. It held that DEI falls within that framework because DEI expresses the view that excluding historically disadvantaged groups is undesirable.

In its analysis, Ars Technica notes that the Supreme Court may have further chances to step in if the case continues. The outlet calls the court's restraint striking, because the justices could have objected to anything from the venue to the viewpoint-discrimination finding. Ars Technica suggests that other courts may take the decision as a sign that the government's anti-DEI efforts stand on weak legal footing.