UK tribunal dismisses £2bn PlayStation Store class action

The tribunal found that physical games and rival consoles gave PlayStation owners real alternatives. It rejected the claim that Sony's 30 percent cut inflated prices by about 20 percent.

GadgetsPublished
PlayStation 5 - Play Like Never Before
Image: Sony · Source
What happened
A UK competition tribunal threw out a £2 billion class action accusing Sony of overcharging through the PlayStation Store.
What’s new
The tribunal ruled that disc-based games and competing consoles constrained Sony's pricing, rejecting the monopoly argument.
Why it matters
About 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners will not receive the roughly £162 each the claim could have won them.

A UK competition tribunal on 17 November dismissed a class action against Sony, Engadget reports. The suit accused the company of using its control of the PlayStation Store to inflate prices for digital games.

Consumer advocate Alex Neill filed the case in 2022, representing roughly 12.2 million PlayStation owners in the UK, and sought £2 billion in damages. The claim argued that Sony's grip on the store let it take a 30 percent cut, and that games would cost about 20 percent less without that control. According to Engadget, eligible players could have received roughly £162 each if the case had succeeded. Sony countered that allowing third-party storefronts would be prohibitively costly and would weaken security and performance.

The tribunal sided with Sony. It found that players had alternatives in physical copies and rival consoles, and called the idea that they were locked into a closed ecosystem "not credible". It also rejected the estimate that prices would have been 20 percent lower. The tribunal pointed to evidence that consumers were willing to switch consoles when game prices rose. It also pointed to internal Sony research cautioning that pricing out of line with Xbox would cost the company customers.

The outcome contrasts with a ruling by the same tribunal against Apple last year. In that case the tribunal found the 30 percent commission Apple takes on App Store digital sales to be an abuse of dominance. Engadget notes that Sony plans to gradually drop physical editions of new PlayStation releases.